Twenty-five years ago tomorrow night, on April 5, 1992, I lost my sister Lucy to suicide. She was 31, I was 28, and I vowed forever after that I would live my life for two.
Twenty-five years ago on Thursday morning, I rose and learned the news. I never knew at what hour, exactly, she’d swallowed a mess of useless psych meds and curled up on her bed with a stuffed bear to wait. Probably it happened before midnight. I had returned late from a few days away, and I was feeling exhausted and nauseated and achy. But the answering machine was blinking that night, so I pressed “play.”
Two messages, both from Lucy. I hadn’t told her I’d be away. Those were the days before cell phones. She had no way of reaching me. No way of even knowing I was out of town.
In the first message, left around 8 p.m., she was desperate. Sobbing. Pleading with me to pick up. Ame Ame Ame Ame. Please. Please be there. Please. Ame Ame Ame.
Oh, my God, I said. Oh my God, oh my God.
And then the second message played. She left it, I think, around 10 p.m., and she sounded perfectly normal. Am fine now, Ame! Don’t worry about me. Everything’s okay. Sorry about the earlier call. No need to phone. Feeling much better. I love you!
So I went to bed. I didn’t try calling her back. Because she was okay, right?
The next morning, the phone rang early. I lay in bed and let the caller leave a message. A few minutes later, I listened to it: an old family friend asking me to call him as soon as I woke. It was important, he said. It had to do with Lucy, he said. Please call, he said.
I knew immediately that she was dead. I called my friend and got his son. “I’m so sorry,” he said. I asked him if Lucy had killed herself. “Yes,” he said. “I’m so sorry.” I told him I was sorry he had to bear the news. I said this because no one should ever have to bear that news. I thanked him, and hung up.
I thought of Lucy’s second message. She’d left it, I was sure, after resolving to die. She’d left it because she didn’t want me to try calling her back and then worry through the night. She wanted me to get a good night’s rest before learning my sister was dead. It was so caring of her. So typical. So Lucy.
I held my husband and called my mother. She told me Lucy had OD’d. And I said, Mama. Mama. Mama.
“Oh, honey,” Mama said. “The poor thing. She’s not suffering any longer.”
No. No, you’re right, Mama. She’s not. That’s true. She’s not.
“Poor, sweet Lucy.”
Poor, sweet Lucy.
She was the sweetest person. The bravest person. The smartest person. The wisest, the goofiest, the most credulous and curious and radiant — a small, beautiful, interesting, interested, fiercely true human being who played Chopin as though she knew him and greeted the world with wonder despite her pain.
Burdened with unyielding psychiatric problems, she had spent too many years of her life bouncing from psych hospital to psych hospital and useless meds to useless meds and wrong diagnosis to wrong diagnosis, settling finally on temporal lobe epilepsy with a complex array of psychological issues on the side. The upshot: She was suicidal. Pretty much all the time, she was suicidal. Even when she put on a sunny face for friends, she was suicidal. Even when she was busy talking me through my latest silly man-woe, she was suicidal. She was almost never not suicidal.
She had tried once before, swallowing earlier fistfuls of those useless meds and awaking from a coma with a renewed appetite for living. I’ve written about that before. I’ve written sundry other blog posts describing our sisterly adventures, like that time I damn-near died hiking with her on Arthur’s Seat in Edinburgh and then that time we both damn-near died in a car crash. I also wrote about her in my first memoir, House of Holy Fools; it’s a safe bet I’ll be writing about her again. How can I not?
Even after 25 years, I miss her. I’m spilling a few tears as I write this, proof that you never really “get over” the death of a loved one, you just make your path through life around it. You take all that you learned from your absent treasure — all that they showed you, all that they shared with you, all of the life and love between you — and you wrap it around your shoulders and chest like a blanket against the cold. That’s my Lucy. She warms me still. She shows me how to live and love and always will.
She lived the way we all should live: without fear, restraint, self-consciousness, selfishness, small-mindedness, duplicity, cruelty or guile. She loved the way we all should love: with her whole being. She faced this world the way we all should face it: squarely. She embraced it in its fullness despite her own mysterious torment, and she lived life as though she meant it, as though it mattered, as though it harbored miracles. It was never easy for her, but she stuck it out as long as she could with as much joy as she could. And when she couldn’t, just before dying, just because she couldn’t take a breath on this earth without loving, she made one last phone call so her kid sister could get some sleep.
27 thoughts on “the love that lucy taught me”
Dear Amy: Stunning and stunningly beautiful. Carl
Oh, Carl. Thank you and bless you.
Ive been got a called also,
are chosen ..🕊✌🐝
Take care, Shan.
Thank you for writing what you write.
And thank you for reading and posting!
Amy, I am hours away from losing my dearest father in this living room. You have just soothed any doubt that I can go on alone because I will never be alone! Each of us has the choice to be the beautiful amalgam of the gifts we have received from our most precious companions in life, whether friends or family. I am alive and so are you and we are blessed to be connected by that giant known as Lucy!!!!! PS just thinking of her makes me 25 years YOUNGER!!!!
Bless you, dear Sue! We are indeed connected. Lucy gave me so much, and she continues to give me so much, through all of the light she beamed around her and all of the friends she made. Take care and much love as you see your father through to the next world. Many many hugs across the ether – I hope we can see each other in the real world soon. xoxo.
Thank you, Amy. This is really beautiful. I lost my sister six weeks ago to cancer and find your words to be of great comfort .
Lois, I am so very sorry for your loss, but I’m grateful you found some small comfort in my words. Your sister will always be with you – and she’ll never be less vivid.
I can appreciate your pain. We lost our 44 year old son to Suicide 3 years ago.
And he too smiled through all his pain while taking care of everyone else. Someday maybe we will be able to accept that these incredible beings were placed in each of our lives to teach us certain lessons. And only through their love and then their leaving are we able to fully grasp some of the concepts.
Chris – again, I am so very sorry. “Incredible beings” — yes, that’s exactly right. I continue to learn from my sister, and I’m learning from her even now. Bless you. Thanks to you and Jim for reading my post and reaching out here.
I am so deeply sorry, Jim. I can’t know the depth of your grief, but I know the depths of your love for your son. Take care.
That was a beautiful tribute. We should all be talking openly about mental health and suicide.
Thanks so much — and I agree. It needs to be discussed without fear or judgment. Only by sharing our stories can we combat the stigma.
Astonishingly devastating. Bless you, AB.
Bless you and thank you, Roger!
As usual dear daughter– you nailed it Love Dan/Dad
Thanks and love!
Powerful and so true. Many thanks for sharing, I too have lost a sister and am quite familiar with living with the pain and sense of loss. ((HUGS))
I wish we didn’t have this in common – I’m so sorry for your loss – but thank you for visiting and posting here. Take care, and hugs back!
For you and Lucy, I will try to love my two sisters a little more…..
Bless all three of you, Lauren.
Hi Amy, I am so sorry for your loss. I hope your writings will help people understand how complex mental illness is and that some people make a solid effort to get well, but health and happiness still elude them. — From your former colleague Chris Sturgis, who has read more than one of your books, so is now elevated to Fan Status.
Thank you so much, Chris. I can only hope that telling my story helps someone in some small way.